Essays

Some Hearts at Christmas Time (Annotated Readings)

Share
Tweet
Email

Hagoth

Some hearts find peace[1]I’d had zero luck getting my wife to share in my love of Low till this song came out; though she now has a habit of requesting “that one sad Low song,” and I’m like, honey, you’re gonna … Continue reading
A sort of release[2]A “sort” of release, not an actual release—similar to how Christmas looks forward to a future redemption, but is not the redemption itself
Not found beneath[3]Low is also named for the 1977 David Bowie album, btw
A Christmas tree[4]Though ostensibly an Indie song, a similar sentiment is expressed in Mariah Carries’ “All I Want For Christmas Is You,” and Kelly Clarkson’s “Underneath the Tree”

Some hearts are lost[5]Released December of 2016, the open question is: was this song written in response to Election 2016, or was such such an (un-)happy coincidence?
They’re tempest tossed[6]Isaiah 54:11
Born on their knees[7]Born not just in the sense of giving birth, but of being carried—that is, both the Nativity and the Atonement
They lost what they need[8]But then, haven’t we all; that is, heartbreak at Christmas is a feature, not a bug—just as suffering generally isn’t the exception, but the rule

Some hearts will break at Christmastime[9]But not all…
Some hearts are made too whole, too fine[10]If you’re heart isn’t breaking, it’s because you haven’t been paying attention

Some hearts will break at Christmastime[11]My Mom died of cancer; my uncle took his own life; my grandparents died of old age, which is supposedly the best case scenario—again, a heartbreaking Christmas isn’t an aberration, but an … Continue reading
Our hearts are made too whole, too fine[12]The lyrics have shifted from “Some hearts” to “Our hearts”—that is, this song is a reminder not just to be aware of and care for others during this Holiday season, but to care for your own … Continue reading

References

References
1 I’d had zero luck getting my wife to share in my love of Low till this song came out; though she now has a habit of requesting “that one sad Low song,” and I’m like, honey, you’re gonna have to be a lot more specific than that
2 A “sort” of release, not an actual release—similar to how Christmas looks forward to a future redemption, but is not the redemption itself
3 Low is also named for the 1977 David Bowie album, btw
4 Though ostensibly an Indie song, a similar sentiment is expressed in Mariah Carries’ “All I Want For Christmas Is You,” and Kelly Clarkson’s “Underneath the Tree”
5 Released December of 2016, the open question is: was this song written in response to Election 2016, or was such such an (un-)happy coincidence?
6 Isaiah 54:11
7 Born not just in the sense of giving birth, but of being carried—that is, both the Nativity and the Atonement
8 But then, haven’t we all; that is, heartbreak at Christmas is a feature, not a bug—just as suffering generally isn’t the exception, but the rule
9 But not all…
10 If you’re heart isn’t breaking, it’s because you haven’t been paying attention
11 My Mom died of cancer; my uncle took his own life; my grandparents died of old age, which is supposedly the best case scenario—again, a heartbreaking Christmas isn’t an aberration, but an inevitability
12 The lyrics have shifted from “Some hearts” to “Our hearts”—that is, this song is a reminder not just to be aware of and care for others during this Holiday season, but to care for your own heart, too. A broken heart can remind you that you have one; but, it’s still broken—but then, we are supposed to have a broken heart and a contrite spirit…
Share
Tweet
LinkedIn
Email
Print